| One third of the patients
who suffer from coronary artery disease also have peripheral vascular disease
viz. Stenosis in aortic arch vessels, mesenteric or renal vessels, ileo-femoral
or leg vessels and aneurysm of abdominal aorta. The prevalence of comorbid
coronary disease in patients with peripheral vascular disease may exceed
50 percent1. Such comorbidity is expected given the similarities
in natural history, treatment modalities and the prognosis in different
arterial beds2.
As our understanding of cardiovascular and cerebrovascular
system has increased it has become more prudent to simply refer to all
of them as a global vascular system and their management as global vascular
therapy. Recently technical advancements in the endovascular therapy of
these global vascular disorders have brought together the skills of interventional
cardiologists, interventional radiologists and vascular surgeons. As a
result very recently a new super specialty of global endovascular interventions
has come up and formal training with input from vascular surgery, interventional
radiology, vascular medicine and interventional cardiology is being given
at 3 centres in United States and 1 in France. A trained global vascular
interventionist has sound knowledge of the pathophysiology and natural
history of these multi vascular disorders. He can provide comprehensive
clinical evaluation and treatment. He can have important inputs in vascular
laboratory, and also help to expand research programs and provide benefits
from educational programs to population at large. Cardiologists because
of the nature of their training are most suited to further train and specialize
as global endovascular specialists. They have the basic coronary interventional
skills, are experienced in the management of complications and have access
to the catheterization laboratory. They also have ample experience in providing
evidence-based medicine and control their own referrals (hence are not
dependent on outside referrals).
In the following paragraphs, we would be discussing
about the advent and advancements of interventional techniques for coronary
artery disease and subsequently the application of the same techniques
in other vascular beds. Quite often the same patient has multiple vascular
pathologies and generally all of them are treated in the same sitting by
similar endovascular techniques (global revascularization strategies).
Interventions
For Coronary Artery Disease
The pathology of atherosclerotic plaque has been
known since last 30 years but the real breakthrough in the treatment occurred
when Andreas Gruentzig did the first coronary angioplasty on September
16, 1977. Gruentzig inspired by the Dotter's (interventional Radiologist)
technique3 for peripheral vascular disease and by Porstmann's
peripheral latex balloon, further developed noncompliant low profile angioplasty
balloons. This marked the beginning of the era of endovascular interventions.
Initial angioplasty balloon catheters were over
the wire and had poor steer ability and larger profile. In the 80's further
refinements lead to the development of low profile monorail balloons and
soft tipped guiding catheters and steerable guide wires. All these improved
the immediate success of angioplasty from 83 to 93 percent. With the technical
advancements in procedure, expertise and hardware, the indications broadened
and soon multivessel angioplasty come in vogue. In the NHLBI
PTCA registry survival rates were 79 and 78
percent for angioplasty of one and two vessels respectively. However, the
restenosis rates were around 35-40 percent and rate of acute or subacute
occlusion was about 6-17 percent4.
Soon this technique of balloon angioplasty was
extended to other arterial trees with variable success. However, two important
issues viz - subacute closure and restenosis remained to be tackled. In
80's and early 90's research and technical advancements were made in these
spheres.
Various debulking devices viz DCA, Rotablator
and TEC were developed. Although a lot of hype was created initially after
large-scale trials they were found not to have significant benefits in
reducing restenosis. However each of them do have some niche application
in coronary and vascular interventions. Directional atherectomy (DCA) which
was introduced by John Simpson, is presently preferred for eccentric, ostial
and bifurcation lesions, while Rotablator, a device developed by David
Auth is good for debulking long, calcified and fibrotic lesions. This consists
of a diamond-studded burr that spins at a rate of 150,000 to 200,000 rpm
and selectively pulverizes non elastic tissue to particles <3 microns
in diameter. However studies like Excimer Laser, Rotablator and Angioplasty
Comparison (ERBAC) trial8 and comparison of Balloon Angioplasty versus
Rotational Atherectomy (COBRA)9 have not shown any better long-term outcome
in preventing restenosis. Lasers can be delivered by guide wire, balloon
catheter (developed by Spears) or by fluorescence-ablation technique. Although
it has not shown to have any advantage in reducing restenosis, it has a
niche application in improving immediate success in aorto-ostial lesions,
un dilatable lesions, calcific and long lesions, SVG grafts disease, in-stent
restenosis and total occlusions.
Newer thrombectomy devices like - Posses AngioJet
and Acolysis and lately Rescue and X-Sizer devices have helped in a great
way in removing recent thrombus from vessels and bypass graft. Intra Vascular
Ultrasound, Angioscopy and Doppler flow wire greatly facilitate catheter
interventions in both coronary and other vascular trees.
Jacques Puel at Toulourse did the first human
coronary stent implantation in France in March 1986. Soon the balloon expendable
stent design was introduced, the prototype being the Palmaz-Schatz stent.
Present indications of stenting are a bail out procedure for acute vessel
closure after PTCA, to improve the suboptimal result of balloon angioplasty
and elective/de novo stenting for reducing restenosis.
Bene stent and stress studies have emphasized
the benefits of stenting over balloon angioplasty in reducing restenosis
from 32 to 22 percent and 42 to 32 percent respectively in arteries. Today
intracoronary stenting is carried out in majority of the angioplasty procedures.
At Escorts Heart Institute And Research Centre, New Delhi where we perform
close to 1900 angioplasties a year, stents are placed in about 75 percent
of the cases. Besides reducing the restenosis rate from 40 percent to less
than 20 percent, stents have almost avoided the need of standby coronary
artery bypass surgery. Different types of stents are available for different
lesion characteristics. Generally, they fall into the following categories
- slotted tube stents, second-generation tubular stents, modular zigzag/hybrid
stents, coil stents, self-expanding stents and biodegradable (temporary)
stents. Their choice depends on the vessel size and characteristics, lesion
length and position, calcification and side branch accessibility. Although
stents have reduced the restenosis rates they still have not fully solved
the problem of restenosis that still occurs in about 20 percent of cases.
Even though we have different techniques like
Rotational Atherectomy, Laser, Re stenting after debulking, today in stent
restenosis is the greatest challenge to an Interventionist. The newer developments
in preventing restenosis are drugs, endovascular radiation (brachy therapy)
or gene therapy. Trapidis (Triazolopyrimidine); a platelet derived growth
factor receptor blocker has shown to reduce the restenosis rate by 15.5
percent (compared to aspirin alone) (p<0.01)7. Probucol,
an antioxidant when started one month in advance also was found to reduce
restenosis in PART study (p<0.001)8. Endovascular radiation
and brachy therapy showed very promising results in IRIS, SCRIPPS, WRIST
trials.
The future direction in preventing acute thrombosis
after angioplasty and preventing restenosis and in an alternative way of
revascularization by angiogenesis is directed towards Gene Therapy. Future
endeavours in the gene therapy will be on stents transected with endothelial
cell lining to prevent thrombosis and restenosis; and with gene encoding
angiogenesis factor for promoting developments of collaterals. Antisense
inhibition of genes encoding the heavy chain of non-muscle myosin also
appears to be promising.
Endovascular
Interventions In Peripheral Vasculature
Along with the advancements in coronary interventions,
similar technological and therapeutic advancement have occurred in the
domain of vascular interventions. Diagnostic angioplasty is complemented
and in same cases even supplemented by digital subtraction techniques,
duplex sonography, intravascular ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging.
Balloon angioplasty, stents, lasers, rotational and directional atherectomy,
posses, axolysis, X sizer, Rescue, Hydrolyser, thrombectomy, intravascular
brachy therapy and gene therapy have similarly been applied in different
vascular beds. Moreover complex vasculopathies like aortic and covered
endovascular stent grafts now successfully treat vascular aneurysm and
aortic dissections percutaneously. Carotid artery stenosis is now routinely
treated by percutaneous endovascular technique of stent-supported angioplasty
with or without cerebral protection. Renal artery and mesenteric artery
stenosis no longer requires a complex surgical bypass procedures and can
easily be treated by stent supported angioplasty.
Over the last 5 years most of the vascular pathologies
are being treated effectively by endovascular techniques. The morbidity
and mortality with these techniques is much lower than the surgical procedures.
As a result many vascular surgeons are forced to learn and practice these
procedures.
In the ensuing paragraphs we would be briefly
discussing the status of some of the vascular interventions and also share
our experience at the Escorts Heart Institute.
The Percutaneous
Management of Renovascular Disease
Recognition, Interventional Strategies
and Future Approaches
Renal artery stenosis is currently being diagnosed
more frequently because of the improved ability of ultrasonography and
tomographic-densitometric techniques to recognize it and also because of
a growing practice among the cardiologists to do renal angiography in patients
undergoing coronary angiography. It usually presents with renovascular
hypertension, (which is the most common cause of secondary hypertension)
in 0.5 to 5 percent cases; renal insufficiency (present in 10 to 15% of
cases); recurrent attacks of acute pulmonary edema (which is usually sudden),
and deterioration of renal functions after initiation of ACE inhibitor
therapy.
There are three main etiologies of renal artery
stenosis; atherosclerosis in 80 percent of the cases and fibromuscular
dysplasia and Takayashu Arteritis in remaining 20 percent of the cases.
The diagnosis of renal artery stenosis can be made of Colour Doppler ultrasonography,
multiplane abdominal aortograms (AP, LAO 30°, and RAO 30° views),
magnetic resonance imaging, computed tomography or angiography.
The risk of progression of renal stenosis to total
occlusion is high in lesions with >60% stenosis and treatment is warranted
in any patient with stenosis >75%.
The first aspect of medical treatment of this
condition is to reduce systemic blood pressure. However, a lower blood
pressure also lowers renal perfusion pressure and eventually this may actually
worsen the renal failure. Surgical treatment has been shown to be superior
to medical therapy but is associated with a mortality rate of 2 to 7 percent
(mean 5.6%) and an elevated risk of deterioration of renal functions. Renal
angioplasty (PTA) and stenting is currently the treatment of choice. Patients
with fibromuscular dysplasia may benefit from balloon dilatation alone,
with excellent results. Less favorable results are obtained in ostial atherosclerotic
lesions, where stenting is warranted due to a higher incidence of recoil,
disease progression and restenosis.
The femoral approach is used in 99 percent of
cases, with a 6- to 8-F. Renal guiding catheter placed directly in front
of the ostium of the renal artery, enabling the passage of the guidewire.
Balloon angioplasty should be performed first, and in case of an unsatisfactory
result, a stent can be placed. Introducing the guiding catheter across
the lesion, then slowly retracting the guide catheter, leaving the stent
across the lesion, should place the stent. The stent should be deployed
at high pressures (12 bars), should protrude about 1 mm into aorta, and
should be dilated afterward with a larger balloon.
Michel Henry et al have performed renal stenting
in a total of 237 patients with 100 percent success rate. Majority of their
cases had ostial disease and presented with hypertension. Majority of the
stent were the Palmaz, AVE, and NIR stents.
There were 3 procedural complications: 1 patient
(0.4%) died, 1 patient (0.4%) had a perirenal hematoma, and stent thrombosis
occurred in 1 patient (0.4%). The mean follow-up period for all patients
was 29 months. Restenosis was observed in 12 percent of the ostial lesions
and in 10.5 percent of the non-ostial lesions. The restenosis rate was
17.3 percent for arteries <5 mm in diameter and 10.0 percent in arteries
>6 mm in diameter. Treatment of restenosis is redo renal angioplasty, which
is associated with a 12 percent restenosis rate. In their series hypertension
was cured in 19 percent, improved in 60 percent, and remained unchanged
in 21 percent. The mean systolic blood pressure reduced from 183+/-25 mmHg
before stenting to 142+/-17 mmHg after stenting. Renal functions improved
in 30 percent, remained unchanged in 66 percent and deteriorated in 4 percent,
which is in concordance with the current literature. The experience in
Escorts Heart Institute & Research Centre is given in Table 1.
RENAL ARTERY STENTING - Escorts Heart Institute
And Research Centre Experience
No. Of Patients
No. Of Arteries Treated
Sex
Males
Females |
59
61
48
11 |
| Site Of Stenosis
Ostial
Non Ostial
Bypass Graft
|
53
7
1 |
| Lesion Characteristics
Mean % Stenosis
Mean Length
|
80 + 10.8% (70 - 100%)
10.9 + 4.2 mm (5 - 20 mm) |
| Etiology
Atherosclerosis
Arteritis
Fibromuscular Dysplasia
|
57
2
2 |
| Symptomatic
Hypertension
Renal Failure
Recurrent Pulmonary Edema
|
44
36
6
3 |
| Asymptomatic Combined Procedures
PTCA
Carotid Stenting
Subclavian Stenting
Iliac Stenting
|
15
9
4
1
4 |
Immediate Results
Procedural Success
Reduction Of Stenosis
Before Stenting
After Stenting
Systolic B.P
Before Stenting
After Stenting
Diastolic B.P
Before Stenting
After Stenting |
100%
80+10.2% (70-100%)
2.3 + 1.4%
180+22mmHg
138 + 19 mmHg
110+14mmHg
86 + 11.6 mmHg |
| Renal Failure
Improved
Unchanged
Worsened
|
3
3
0 |
| Acute Pulmonary Edema
Cured
|
3 |
| 6 months Follow-up
No. Of Patients
No. Of Arteries
Restenosis
|
28
36
2 |
Renal functions can deteriorate after renal angioplasty
in up to 22 percent of cases because of atheroemboli during the procedure,
contrast material, lesion recurrence, or lesion progression. The embolic
phenomena can be avoided by using distal protection devices such as the
PrecuSurge device. This device was successfully used in 16 patients, non
of whom had deterioration in renal function and three of whom in fact showed
improvement.
Endoluminal Stent Grafts of
Exclusion of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysms and Dissection; Overview of Devices
and Clinical Experiences
The US Food and Drug Administration have recently
approved some devices for the exclusion of aortic aneurysms. The diagnosis
of abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) has been occurring with increasing frequency
in the last two decades, probably because of an increase in utilization
of modern imaging techniques. During the last 20 years, extensive research
has been done in the field of stent grafts for the percutaneous treatment
of this potentially catastrophic disease.
Currently there are two devices on the verge of
receiving FDA approval viz the AneuRx (Medtronic), made of Dacron with
a metal exoskeleton; and the Ancure (Guidant), also covered with Dacron.
These two devices are comparable and need longer follow-up data to assess
their safety and application. Other devices that are being released include
the Zenith endovascular graft (Cook); the Corvita Endovascular Graft (Corvita
Corporation). The Gore Hemobahn PTFE covered graft, the Powerlink graft
and the Talent device.
Occlusion time is significantly less with the
percutaneous approach than in surgical controls. Blood loss is also significantly
less, about 433 mL in the percutaneous patients compared with 1500mL in
the surgical group. Length of stay in ICU was 20.6 hours and total hospitalization
time was 3.4+/-2.7 days, versus 9.4+/-0.8 days in the surgical arm. The
Achilles heel of this procedure is endo leak at the edges of the device.
Other complications include atheroembolism, limb thrombosis, hypogastric
artery occlusion, colonic ischemia, and reoperation.
Only 40 percent of the patients with aortic aneurysms
are amenable to percutaneous repair, and hybrid procedures are being developed
whereby a graft is placed in the aorta and communicates to one of the iliac
arteries. The other iliac artery is occluded with an occluder or coil and
a femoral-femoral bypass is done surgically in order to provide blood flow
to the contralateral side. Endoleaks, Reintervention, Device migration,
Collateralisation through Lumbar and accessory arteries, Customization
of the device and large profile of the device are the present challenges
in endovascular treatment of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm.
Stent supported
carotid angioplasty
Significant Internal Carotid artery stenosis is
responsible for more than 60 percent of the strokes and is the third major
cause of death. Stent supported carotid angioplasty has the potential to
prevent strokes in thousand of patients and offers a number of potential
advantages over conventional surgical revascularization by carotid stenting.
Results of the pooled data of the global experience of carotid stenting
on more than 3000 cases indicate that carotid stenting is safe and effective
in reducing the incidence of stroke. The risk of cerebral embolism is reduced
to less than 1 percent by the use of various techniques of cerebral protection
like the Theron & Henry-Amor-Rufenach-Fried techniques. PercuSurge
Guard wire system and the Angioguard Filter device. Stent placement significantly
reduces the chances of acute closure, vessel recoil and restenosis. At
the Escorts Heart Institute we have performed 37 carotid stenting procedures
and we were one of the first few centres in the world to use PercuSurge
cerebral protection during carotid stenting. Our results are shown in Table
2.
CAROTID STENTING - Escorts Heart
Institute And Research Centre Experience
No of Patients
Age
Sex
Male
Female
Unilateral Stenosis
Bilateral Stenosis
|
37
67.5 + 7.2 Years
28
9
26
11 |
| Combined Procedures
Subclavian stenting
Vertebral stenting
Common Carotid stenting
PTCA
Renal Stenting
Illiac and Femoral Stenting
|
4
3
3
7
9
8 |
Procedural Success
Immediate Results
% Stenosis
Before Stenting
Post Stenting
Periprocedural
Bradycardia
Hypotension |
100%
88.2 + 7.2%
13 + 4.2%
4 (3 Responded To Atropine 1 Required Temporary
Pacing )
3 |
| Complications
Minor Stroke
Prolonged Hypotension
|
1
4 (Req. Vasopressor Support For 24 Hours) |
11 Months Follow Up
No Of Patients
Clinical
Asymptomatic
Strokes / Tia
Restenosis
Death |
23
23
0
0
0 |
Stenting
for coarctation of aorta in adults
Coarctation of the aorta is also one of the treatable
causes of hypertension. It is also associated with high risk of cerebral
hemorrhage and sudden death. Both angioplasty and surgery are viable options
in childhood but until recently stenting was not carried out in adult patients
of coarctation. Recent data suggests that stenting can be safely and effectively
performed in these patients. However the overall world experience is very
limited. We have treated 16 patients of adult coarctation and our experience
is shown in Table 3.
STENTING FOR ADULT COARCTATION - Escorts Heart
Institute and Research Centre Experience
No. Of Patients
Age
Sex
Male
Female |
16
31.95 + 14.8 Years
(18 - 56 Years)
10
6 |
Presentation
Systemic Hypertension
Associated Coronary Artery Disease |
16
1 |
Procedure
PTA
PTA + Stenting
Indication For Stenting
Denovo
Dissection
Mean Stent Diameter
Mean Stent Length
Stents : Palmaz
Wall Stent |
5
6
13.95 + 3.20 Mm
(5 - 20 Mm)
40 + 6.8 Mm
11
1 |
Immediate Results
Procedural Success
Pressure Gradiant
Before Stenting
After Stenting |
100%
76 + 24.5mmhg (50 - 120 mmHg)
28.5 + 14.25 Mmhg (4 - 42 mmHg) |
Intermediate Follow Up - 12 Months
Restenosis
Stent Displacement
Aneurysm Formation
Hypertension
Decreased
Unchanged
Cured |
0
0
0
8
6
2 |
Conclusion
As multiple vasculopathies often coexist in a
patient, a global approach of endovascular revascularization is warranted,
with a view to provide complete and lasting relief at low risk and morbidity.
This trend of global revascularization is becoming more and more popular
and cost effective and is being adapted by leading centres all over the
world. We have adapted this strategy in the last one-year and of the 1900
coronary interventions performed annually at our centre, as a part of global
revascularization strategy about 10% of the patients also have endovascular
interventions for carotid, renal, vertebral, subclavian, aorta-iliac or
limb vessels. Fig.1 depicts one of our cases of unstable angina where coronary
stenting was done along with carotid, left renal stenting, as the patient
was also having recurrent TIAs and uncontrolled hypertension.
Bibliography
Michael J Pantecost, Michael H Criqui,
Gerald Dorros, et al. Guidelines for Peripheral Percutaneous Transluminal
Angioplasty of the Abdominal Aorta and the Lower Extremity Vessels. Circulation
Vol 89, No 1 512-528.
Rose GA. The diagnosis of ischaemic
heart pain and intermittent claudication in filed surveys. Bull WHO 1962;
27: 654-658.
Dotter CT, Judkins MP. Transluminal
treatment of arteriosclerotic obstruction; description of new technique
and preliminary report of its application. Circulation 1964; 30:654.
Wireny L, Plass R, Porstmann W.
Long-term results in 100 consecutive patients treated with transluminal
angioplasty. Radiology 1974; 99: 19-26.
Gruentzig AR, King SB, Schlumf M,
Siegenthaler W. Long term follow-up after percutaneous transluminal coronary
angioplasy: the early Zurich experience. N Engl J Med 1987; 316: 1127-32.
Maresta A, Balducelli M, Cantini
L, et al. For the STARC investigators. Trapidil (triazolopyrimidine), a
platelet derived growth factor antagonist, reduces restenosis after percutaneous
transluminal coronary angioplasty: Results of the randomized double blind
STARC study. Circulation 1994; 90: 2710-5.
Hisahi Yokoi, Hiroyuki Daida, Youchi
Kuwabara et al. Effectiveness of an antioxidant in preventing restenosis
after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty: The Probucol angioplasty
restenosis trial. J Am Coil Cariol 1997; 30:855-862.
Serruys PW, de jaegere P, Keimeneij
F, et al. On behalf of the BENESTENT study group: a comparison of balloon
expandable stent implantation with balloon angioplasty in patients with
coronary artery disease. N Engl J Med 1994; 331: 489-95.
Fishman DL, Leon MB, Baim DS et al.
A randomized comparison of coronary stent placement and balloon angioplasty
in the treatment of coronary artery disease. N Engl J Med 1994; 331: 496-501.
|